Career exploration

Ausbildung (vocational training) or start working right away: Which is better?

By the ChancenPlus editorial teamLast updated 4 min read

In short

For most people, an Ausbildung is the better choice in the long run. With a vocational qualification, you have more job options and better chances of advancement. Working right away can make sense if you need money quickly or want to gain experience first. You can still start an Ausbildung later.

What's the difference between an Ausbildung and working?

In an Ausbildung, you learn a trade or profession and get a recognized qualification at the end. If you start working right away, you earn money immediately, but without a qualification.

A dual Ausbildung usually takes two to three and a half years. You learn at the company and at Berufsschule (vocational school). In return, you receive an Ausbildungsvergütung (training allowance). The Berufsbildungsgesetz (Vocational Training Act) sets a minimum amount for it.

What are the pros and cons of each path?

An Ausbildung gives you security for the future. Working right away gets you money faster.

AspectAusbildungWorking right away
QualificationYou get a recognized vocational qualification.You get an Arbeitszeugnis (employment reference), but no qualification.
Money at the startYou get a training allowance.You usually get a full wage right away.
Money laterSkilled workers usually earn more than unskilled workers.Without a qualification, wages often rise more slowly.
Job optionsMore positions are open to you, including skilled positions.You'll mainly find helper and temp jobs.
Getting aheadYou can pursue further training later, for example to become a Meister (master craftsperson).For many further training programs, you first need a qualification.

When does it make sense to start working right away?

Working right away makes sense if you need money right now or don't yet know which career suits you. In that case, plan the job as an interim step.

A job shows you what work looks like day to day. You find out what you're good at and what you're not. Some companies later offer good temporary workers an Ausbildung position. Feel free to ask about it.

Important for everyone under 18: If you haven't completed vocational training, the statutory minimum wage doesn't apply to you. That's set out in the Mindestlohngesetz (Minimum Wage Act).

How do I make my decision?

Go through these points honestly. The more of them apply to you, the more an Ausbildung is worth it now.

  • I have an idea of which career interests me.
  • I can get by on a training allowance for a few years.
  • I'd like to work as a skilled worker later on.
  • I'd like to be able to pursue further training later on.
  • I've talked about my plans with my family or a career counselor.

Can I still do an Ausbildung later?

Yes. There's no age limit for an Ausbildung. Many people only start one after a few years of working.

If you've already worked, you bring experience with you. Many companies value that. If you want to earn a qualification alongside your job, the Agentur für Arbeit (employment agency) can help you plan.

More questions about Ausbildung and jobs

Can I shorten an Ausbildung?

Under certain conditions, yes, for example with an Abitur (university entrance qualification) or work experience. Ask your training company or the responsible Kammer (chamber of commerce or crafts).

What if I don't like my Ausbildung?

Talk to your company or your Berufsschule first. Switching to another company or career is possible. Career counseling can help you with this.

Are there also school-based Ausbildung programs?

Yes. Some careers you learn at a Berufsfachschule (full-time vocational school), for example in nursing and care or in the social sector. Whether you get paid depends on the career.

Sources