No. In Germany, there is no legal obligation to give a reason for a rejection. If you do give one, it must be objective and must not relate to any of the characteristics protected under the AGG (General Equal Treatment Act). Even so, short, honest feedback helps applicants move forward.
Is there an obligation to give a reason?
No. No law requires you to tell applicants why you rejected them. A clear, friendly rejection without a reason is legally fine.
But keep the Allgemeines Gleichbehandlungsgesetz (AGG) in mind. It prohibits discrimination on grounds of race or ethnic origin, gender, religion or belief, disability, age or sexual identity.1 This also applies to any reason you write down.
When does giving a reason become risky?
When it provides an indication of discrimination. Then you have to prove that you did not discriminate.2
Applicants who feel discriminated against can assert claims in writing within two months of receiving the rejection.3 A lawsuit must then follow within three months of that written claim.4
| Wording | Problem | Better |
|---|---|---|
| “We’re looking for someone for a young team.” | Refers to age | “We have decided on another person.” |
| “The job is physically very demanding.” | May be aimed at a disability or gender | Describe the requirements objectively in the job ad from the start |
| “Unfortunately, your German isn’t good enough.” | Can be read as referring to origin | Only mention it if the job objectively requires a certain language level |
Is short feedback still worth it?
Yes, if it is objective and relates to the requirements of the job. Applicants can work with it, and your company leaves a good impression.
- Only refer to requirements from the job ad.
- State facts, not impressions of the person.
- Keep it to one or two sentences.
- Show a way forward, for example another job.
- Have a second person proofread sensitive rejections.
Hello Ms. Nowak,
Thank you for your application for the driver position. A class CE driver’s license is required for this position, so we cannot consider you this time.
Through ChancenPlus, you can quickly find suitable jobs, with us or with other companies.
Best regards,
Jonas Keller, Muster Transporte
What do I do if someone asks for the reason?
Respond in a friendly, objective way. You may give a reason, but you don’t have to.
Agree in advance within your team who will answer such questions. One person with clear templates responds more consistently than many individuals.
More questions
May I explain a rejection by phone?
Yes. The same rules apply to a phone call as to an email. Afterwards, briefly note down what you said.
Do I have to say who got the job?
No. Information about other applicants does not belong in a rejection, for data privacy reasons as well.
How long should I keep documents after a rejection?
As long as you need them for possible claims. At ChancenPlus, you set the deletion period between 1 and 6 months.